Academy Award Nominations and Winners: |
| Best Picture |
| Best Director: Stanley Kramer |
★ | Best Actor: Maximilian Schell |
| Best Actor: Spencer Tracy |
| Best Supporting Actress: Judy Garland |
| Best Supporting Actor: Montgomery Clift |
★ | Best Adapted Screenplay: Abby Mann |
| Best Cinematography (Black & White): Ernest Laszlo |
| Best Art Direction (Black & White): Rudolph Sternad; George Milo |
| Best Costume Design (Black & White): Jean Louis |
| Best Film Editing: Frederic Knudtson |
|
Golden Globe Nominations and Winners: |
| Best Picture (Drama) |
★ | Best Director: Stanley Kramer |
★ | Best Actor (Drama): Maximilian Schell |
| Best Supporting Actress: Judy Garland |
| Best Supporting Actor: Montgomery Clift |
| Best Film Promoting International Understanding |
|
Other Awards: |
| New York Film Critics Circle: Best Actor (Schell); Best Screenplay |